We Found the Best Shoes for Bunions (Including Heels!) (2024)

Our analysts and testers have long been impressed with the offerings from New Balance. This pair, in particular, has a flexible knit upper section that can more comfortably accommodate bunions than stiffer materials. Add in a soft foam underfoot and they make an ideal shoe for long runs, quick sprints and walks.

They're strategically designed with more foam at the widest points and more flexibility where they narrow, a feature that our analysts love. Testers also gave this shoe perfect scores for fit, comfort and cushioning, saying they "provide just enough cushioning during your runs" and are "very lightweight and breathable."

Bonus: They're one of the few styles that are available in both wide and extra-wide sizing. The brand does note that they run a little large, so make sure to check out the size chart if purchasing online.

At around $40 a pair (or less if you catch them on sale!), these sneakers are by far the most affordable our list. They're a great choice if you have bunions, since they have a sock-like fit thanks to the stretch knit upper and no laces for easy slip on and off.

One of our testers said, "They didn't look like clunky orthopedic shoes, but they felt as if they were padded with four inches of memory foam." Another raved that "they're easy on, easy off." Podiatrists we spoke to also like how lightweight they are (less than 150 grams per shoe) but they were a bit weary of the thicker heel cushioning.

Compared to other pairs on our list, this style doesn't offer as much support and stability, both of which help promote foot strength. While wide sizes weren't available when we tested, the pair are now available in wide sizing as well.

Orthofeet shoes are designed specifically for people with foot conditions, including bunions. They also come in an exceptionally inclusive size range, with wide, extra-wide and extra-extra-wide widths, so if you have wide feet and a bunion, there should still be enough room in these shoes to accommodate your feet comfortably.

The brand's orthotic insoles are designed to create more stability, along with cushioning throughout and padding in the back. They are one of the heavier styles of shoes we've tested, and that's because they have a mild rocker-style design to help propel you forward when walking.

In our tests, these sneakers received perfect scores for comfort and cushioning, though some testers did note they aren't the most aesthetically pleasing. That said, if you're simply focused on pain relief, it's worth taking note that one of testers said this pair "aided in pain relief with my knees after exercise or walking."

If you struggle with bunions, you might have written off heels completely. We've tested a variety of shoes from this brand and found that the stretchy knit upper is very comfortable while still feeling luxe.

This pair has a 1.77-inch heel, so it gives you just enough lift to elevate your look without being too high. We've found it's possible stand or walk in these heels comfortably for extended periods of time. The shoe comes in two styles: The Melody Basic and the Melody Pro. The Melody Pro comes with upgraded pressure relief insoles.

Note that this style is not machine washable, and the brand recommends cleaning by gently scrubbing the uppers and soles with a clean cloth.

Just because you have a bunion doesn't mean you need to resign yourself to wearing sneakers every day. If you need a cute work shoe that's also comfortable, these stylish loafers from Rothy's come in 13 different colors and patterns like plum twill, leopard print, classic black and more.

Rothy's shoes are a favorite among GH analysts and editors alike, thanks to the brand's comfortable and chic designs. Like other Rothy's shoes, these flats are made with a stretchy knit material that easily accommodates bunions. While these shoes don't come in wide sizes, they also don't run narrow. In fact, according to the brand, the Almond Loafer can run a bit big.

At 150 grams per shoe, these lightweight sneakers from New Balance were not only popular with our testers, but also with our GH analysts and the podiatrists we consulted. The slip-on design features a tongue that stays put for easy on and off, making it a great commuter shoe too.

These shoes have racked up an impressive 69,000 Amazon reviews, plus they're a great value compared to the other shoes on this list. Testers loved these shoes, unanimously saying they would continue wearing them. They appreciated that the front mesh made the shoes breathable and comfy over bunions, though we noted that the midsole is thinner than other picks. While this does mean the shoes offer less cushioning, they're lighter and allow for quicker movement.

Our testers have raved about these sneakers from Brooks, with one reporting that she usually finds "no shoes comfortable to wear, but these are amazing." The pair hit high marks across the board for cushioning, support and traction, with one tester saying, "I didn't even feel like I was running on the pavement while wearing these." GH Senior Analyst Emma Seymour even personally wears them when running on the treadmill.

Prioritizing stability and control, the style features ample cushioning and a comfortable heel. Though Brooks is a popular brand for running shoes, walkers also live this style. The Ghost 15's predecessor (the Ghost 14) has a massive following for being a versatile, supportive sneaker for walkers and runners alike, and from our testers stellar reviews, the Ghost 15 is set to follow in their footsteps.

In recent evaluations, we've tested all kinds of shoes, including more than 50 styles of walking shoes and more than 30 running shoes, as well as hiking shoes, sandals and more.

In addition to evaluating each pair in the Lab, we send them off to consumer testers with a range of shoe sizes and foot shapes. Depending on the test, we have testers walk in the shoes for at least two hours before giving feedback. In some cases (like walking shoes) we saw the shoes in half in our Lab, so podiatrists and other footwear experts can review the cross-section and analyze the efficacy and longevity of the materials. Here are a few other criteria we evaluate when testing shoes:

✔️ Comfort: One of the most important things is how the shoes feel on your feet. Because of this, we rated comfort highly when analyzing testers' feedback, noting the feel of the footbed, tongue and ankle opening.

✔️ Support: The right footbed helps keep your feet properly supported while on the move, reducing strain on your arches. Testers gave extensive feedback on each pair's arch support and fit notes.

✔️ Weight: In the Lab, we weighed each shoe to nix overly clunky styles.

When it comes to bunions (and the pain they might be causing), knowing what to look for when shoe shopping can greatly aid your search. Follow these tips from Dr. Aiyer and our GH footwear experts:

✔️ Wide toebox: The area of the shoe that fits the ball of your foot and your toes is called the toebox, and if you have bunions you definitely want the space there to be wide enough to accommodate. Opt for wide or even extra-wide styles to ensure you have the space you need to be comfortable.

✔️ Materials: A stretch knit material on the upper part of the shoe can allow for more space too, and space is the name of the game when it comes to shoes for bunions. Dr. Aiyer also recommends stiffer material along the bottom of the shoe to create adequate support for the foot.

✔️ Arch support: According to Dr. Aiyer, arch collapse can be connected to bunion development, so stay way from flat shoes with no arch support and opt for a shoe that fits your arch.

✔️ Cushioning: This can vary immensely between types of shoes and preferences between people, so overall go for what makes you most comfortable. If you don't know where to start, generally very cushioned shoes are best for extreme long distance walkers or people with specific injuries who need more support. Try on different styles until you find the sweet spot between too much bulk that can make you feel unbalanced and the correct amount of cushioning to support your foot.

The best shoe for bunions is the shoe that's most comfortable for your specific needs."Ultimately, what works for one person might not work for another," says Dr. Aiyer, who advises going into a shoe store and trying on different styles.

Generally though, you'll want something that's a little stiffer to provide more support and something with a wider toebox and stretchy knit uppers to provide the needed space. On the other hand, some of our testers with bunions found open sandals more comfortable.

Our GH Institute experts also suggest looking for shoes with arch support, as a flat shoe can put more strain on your toes. They also recommend avoiding heels over two inches as they can cause foot pain in general and are likely to cause more of an issue long-term.

While you can't walk around the street barefoot (hello, tetanus!), walking around your house barefoot might have some benefits, though it does depend on a few different factors.

"If you're someone who has more of an extreme case, you've probably also got associated nerve issues," says Dr. Aiyer. Chances are you need to protect your feet because you may not be able to detect sensory disturbances, or the way you walk may be putting pressure in different spots. Diabetics are a classic example of someone who might have these issues." Basically, if you've lost that protective sensation in your feet, put on some shoes.

If you haven't lost any sensation though, walking barefoot can certainly help. Dr. Aiyer does advise that choosing to walk barefoot also needs to come with the dedication to correct the way you're walking. "The non-shoed concept is great, assuming that you're not inadvertently compensating and shifting your weight," he says. Our bodies naturally adjust to avoid and compensate for pain, so if you've had a bunion for a while, your way of walking has probably adjusted so you're not putting as much weight on your big toe. "That's something that happens wether we realize it or not because the body wants to protect itself from pain," Dr. Aiyer points out.

The bottom line: If you're dedicated to readjusting how you distribute your weight, it's a good habit to develop that can help with pain, but if you have no plans to make the needed adjustments, nothing is going to change.

Dr. Aiyer notes that if you've had foot pain for a long time, you might have pretty set walking habits to avoid that pain in the big toe. In this case, he recommends physical therapy to re-learn how to distribute your weight appropriately across your foot.

The Good Housekeeping Institute Textiles Lab has been a leading expert on footwear for decades.

This article was written by Abigail Bailey, who covers everything from kitchen gear to mattresses and smart blinds for GH. For this story, she consulted with Emma Seymour, senior textiles product analyst for the Good Housekeeping Institute. Seymour has been at GH for more than three years, overseeing Lab and consumer tests for a variety of fitness products, including walking shoes, running shoes, hiking shoes, the best yoga mats, workout leggings for every type of exercise, the best sports bras and more. With a degree in fiber science and apparel design from Cornell University, she has extensive research experience, particularly focused on athletic wear. Bailey also spoke to Amiethab “Tabs” Aiyer, M.D., an associate professor of orthopedic surgery at Johns Hopkins University.